Apartments and houses for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Loading...
Loading...Enable notifications and we'll notify you immediately when a new property becomes available for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY on one of the most popular real estate sites!
For Sale
For Rent10 listings
4 Freds Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$2,621,000
3116 sqft
5 beds
4 baths
$841/sqft
August 09, 2026 - Source: trulia.com
New
9 hours ago
10 Point Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
$3,750,000
5386 sqft
5 beds
$696/sqft
August 04, 2026 - Source: realtor.com
New
6 days ago
10 Point Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
$3,750,000
5386 sqft
5 beds
6 baths
$696/sqft
August 04, 2026 - Source: zillow.com
New
6 days ago
10 Point Ln, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
$3,750,000
5386 sqft
5 beds
5 baths
$696/sqft
August 04, 2026 - Source: trulia.com
New
6 days ago
3 Bevan Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$8,500,000
1798 sqft
3 beds
3 baths
$4,727/sqft
July 30, 2026 - Source: realtor.com
New
10 days ago
1-3 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$4,750,000
1851 sqft
3 beds
2 baths
$2,566/sqft
July 27, 2026 - Source: realtor.com
New
14 days ago
6 Great Circle Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$4,995,000
5535 sqft
5 beds
7 baths
$902/sqft
July 22, 2026 - Source: realtor.com
New
19 days ago
6 Great Circle Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$4,995,000
5535 sqft
5 beds
7 baths
$902/sqft
July 22, 2026 - Source: realtor.com +1 more
New
19 days ago
20 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$1,375,000
3 beds
2 baths
July 17, 2026 - Source: realtor.com
New
24 days ago
14 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$2,095,000
3059 sqft
4 beds
3 baths
$685/sqft
July 16, 2026 - Source: realtor.com
New
25 days ago
What's the average cost of properties in Shelter Island Heights, NY?
Based on the last 30 days, the average property price in Shelter Island Heights, NY is $4,217,778.
This is 376.9% higher than the average price of properties for sale in New York.
This is 376.9% higher than the average price of properties for sale in New York.
How often do new properties for sale come on the market in Shelter Island Heights, NY?
On average, a new property is put on the market for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY every 3 days.
Filters
Price Range
$
$
Number of Bedrooms
Number of Bathrooms
Square Feet
sqft
sqft
Notifications turned on!
We'll notify you as soon as a new property becomes available for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY.
Notifications turned off!
We won't send you any more notifications about new properties for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY.
Would you like to be notified as soon as we find a new property for sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY?
To enable notifications, you need to add this page to your iPhone's home screen first:
Tap on icon, then "Add to Home Screen"
Argentina
Brasil
Česko
Canada
Colombia
Deutschland
España
Ελλάδα
France
India
Italia
Magyarország
México
Nederland
Österreich
Polska
Portugal
România
Slovensko
Türkiye
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom
United States